a mediateam website

May issue of The Irish Garden Magazine








Rachel's Journal

Rachel's Journal

Last Post 17 hours ago

The Smell of Paper

05 December 2011 22:46:54
The Smell of Paper

The Smell of Paper

I am really getting stuck into this book at the moment. It is 'Thoughtful Gardening' by Robin Lane Fox and it was probably on many people's list last Christmas. Although I was given it some time ago, it was in a queue after some other books so is only getting read now.

And, as I read, I have my highlighter in hand and I mark the sections I want to remember or the names of plants I want to get. Pause for dramatic effect!...

Now I, like many of my age, was brought up to believe that books are almost sacred. You got yelled at in my house for turning down the corner of a page or leaving a book turned upside down and open on the pages you wanted to keep. The spine would crack, for god's sake, and we would all fall headlong into the abyss of illiteracy!

In my house we opened new books at the middle page and sniffed to appreciate the smell of newly-cut paper. And you never, ever, ever got rid of books. You stored them forever as a testimony to what you knew or as some kind of trophy. But most of all you certainly never destroyed books. Book burning is what they did in Nazi Germany for god's sake!

However, times have changed. Trash is written. Books are disposable. Houses have less space and teachers instruct students which passages to underline in their textbooks and give out if it isn't done.

And I have changed. I highlight passages I want to find again easily, especially in gardening books. Who does the book belong to anyhow and who's use is it for? My kids won't want it after I'm gone. I feel liberated! Oh and, Paddy, this is my roundabout way of saying I wrote on the book you gave me!


Please login to write a comment or click here to register

TheH (Hazel) TheH (Hazel) 05 December 2011 23:12:04

Good on you Rachel! There is nothing like the smell of new paper when you open a book for the first time! I also find it fascinating to find passages that a previous reader has highlighted or underlined, particulalry trying to figure out why they marked that particular bit .... it was when studying as a "mature Student" that I got over the "never mark a book, turn down a page ....etc!


Gracedieu Lass Gracedieu Lass 05 December 2011 23:18:44

Rachel,

When we look at cookery books here at home we notice some pages are completely grubby, with splashes of grease, butter, flour and other evidence of use. The most soiled pages are the ones with the best recipes and the ones which have brought the greatest pleasure.

So, I am delighted that you are finding passages worth marking in the book, hope you enjoy the read. He writes well.

Paddy - still too old-fashioned to mark my own books.  


Periwinkle Periwinkle 05 December 2011 23:29:13

Great journal Rachel! Like Paddy I am still reluctant to mark my books (probably for same reason!) But good onya! Its your book, after all!


Hosta Hosta 05 December 2011 23:29:42

It's an interesting book Rachel, I'm sure you will enjoy it.  I got it last year and while I haven't read it all, I have dipped in to it over the year and enjoyed it.

Ordered Christopher Lloyd's 'Foliage' last night so will have that to keep me going over Christmas.  Have to agree with you about the smell of new paper  :-)


Gracedieu Lass Gracedieu Lass 05 December 2011 23:34:23

You have just reminded me, Margaret, some of C. Lloyd's books have been reissued in paperback. I have two to hand but had forgotten about them. 

Paddy 


Elizabeth7 Elizabeth7 05 December 2011 23:41:45

I can see no valid reason why we should not do as we like with books we own. BUT I would find it nearly impossible to mark a book unless maybe, just maybe if it was a book I was using in order to take an exam.  When I was a child paperbacks had not been thought of and my books were very very precious to me, all hardback. So I have a particular reverence towards the hardback variety and while now and then I might turn down the corner of a paperback never a hardback.

As for making marks in Library books how anyone can do that, but they do.

How many years will it be before Books are replaced by Kindles and the like and the World will be a poorer place.

 


Rachel Rachel 05 December 2011 23:52:23

Ha ha, so true about the cookery books, Paddy!

 


ladygardener ladygardener 05 December 2011 23:53:07

What an admission!! I would have blamed the dog.


Rachel Rachel 05 December 2011 23:56:17

Elizabeth, Kindles are mostly useless for gardening books as they currently have no colour pictures. But it will come. A friend told me you can make your own notes on the pages in your kindle book. But I think that no matter how popular they ever become, there will always be a place for certain hardcopy books. They could be really handy (when the colour option is sorted out) for gardening encyclopaedias!


Rachel Rachel 05 December 2011 23:57:06

Anne, your dog is good. My kids have difficulty with the highlighters!


Rachel Rachel 05 December 2011 23:58:06

Margaret, this book is a cover-to-cover one for me. Really easy reading.


Rachel Rachel 05 December 2011 23:59:04

Hazel & Periwinkle, we are the same ilk!


Rachel Rachel 06 December 2011 00:09:33

Paddy & Margaret, it's sinful what I've done to poor old Mr Lloyd with the pink highlighter!


Jacinta Jacinta 06 December 2011 06:05:00

Oh Rachel, you any I were brought up alike, to appreciate books of all descriptions, and NEVER to dirty, mark, fold down, give away, burn or sell. I'm still at the stage of keeping them in pristine condition. If I come across a passage I need to refer to again and again, bookmarks do the trick for me, until I cross that line. ANd yes, after the smell of compost, paper is the next best thing. Great journal.


fran m fran m 06 December 2011 07:28:13

Great journal, full of memories and connections ;-))


TinaJ TinaJ 06 December 2011 09:02:43

I was given a gardening book many years ago,a book i cherished,one day i opened it to look up something i had seen before in it.only to discover that a lot of the pictures were missing!!my daughter had cut most of the pictures out for a school project!!


Jemo Jemo 06 December 2011 10:12:43

Rachel a very well written piece, shades of Sunday Miscellany!....a wordsmith as well as everything else ...are there any limits to your talent?


Gracedieu Lass Gracedieu Lass 06 December 2011 10:50:42

I mentioned that two of Christopher Lloyd's books had recently been reissued in softback; they are, "Foliage Plants" and "The Adventurous Gardener". No illustrations. £13 each.

His books are always a good read; well written, entertaining and with plenty of plant ideas.  

Paddy 


Jacinta Jacinta 06 December 2011 16:29:06

Oh Tina, I'd kill her. But isn't it grand that your books could provide her with all the info and photos that she needed. I hope she got good marks for it.


TinaJ TinaJ 06 December 2011 17:00:56

Jacinta ,she got good marks,little did her teacher realise she ruined her mams gardening book,it always brings a smile to my face when i open the book 


Myrtle Myrtle 06 December 2011 17:52:26

Great journal! also like the idea of a gardening encyclopaedia on Kindle, we would all be walking round garden centres with them :)


Elizabeth7 Elizabeth7 06 December 2011 18:07:40

I fancy a Plant recognition facility, so you could publish the picture of a plant and request ID and information. Probably be available quite soon.


Moya Moya 06 December 2011 22:44:22

Such a lovely descriptive AND challenging journal. I still find it hard to think about marking a book but I really can see why it's a bit precious to think like that.

Better to open, finger, peruse, read, smell, highlight, underline a book because it means you are getting the maximum value out of it and adding to your knowledge and insight.

Getting a Kindle for Christmas - just for novels and going on hols.


simon craigie simon craigie 07 December 2011 19:12:28

I thought that perhaps reading other members journals would open up my mind, rather than just reading my own! This is a good place to share experiences, just a matter of changing habits! exploring with an open mind, it takes a little time out like time for relaxation, when we stumble across new things we can relate to, things that heighten our awareness of each other, and things going on around us in our very own country, our own environment, our place, that connection of us together rather than me on my own is much stronger, the sense of belonging and sharing. I'd be very interested in attending at Johnstown Garden Centre in January for the Christmas get together. What a great idea. Will there be discounts or will we need any- Guess have a word with Jim Clarke! Johnstown Garden Centre is a lovely place, they have a generous offering.


Rachel Rachel 07 December 2011 19:24:44

You will be added to the next list, Simon. See you at Johnstown.


Keego Keego 07 December 2011 22:51:42

Rachel what a lovely journal I am guilty of the dog ears and the highlighter and the grease marks in my cookery books well used books hence any ones I have to swop will be the ones that did not strike a chord with me and remain completely unmarked


Members

Garden.ie Members

Not a member yet?
Join now to:

Join Now

Existing Members


Forgotten password
 

Garden.ie CLUB

Join Ireland's first online garden club! Share pictures of your garden, make new friends and chat with other gardeners. It's simple to join and free! Register Here

Featured Members


Know-How!

Thousands of gardening facts at your finger tips:


Ask Gerry

Gerry DalyTry our unique advice service from editor Gerry Daly. Got a question right now? Search here to see if it has been answered already:








a mediateam website



©2013 Garden.ie. Mediateam Ltd, Media House, South County Business Park, Leopardstown, Dublin 18.


Tel (+353 1) 2947777 Email info@garden.ie

Website Design by KCO.ie